Crochet Shawl Showdown
Crochet Shawl Pattern Showdown!
There's no doubt that both of these crocheted shawls are fabulous. But which one do you like better? Leave a comment below and let us know.
The winning pattern is the Easy Dreamy Shawl! Get the free crochet shawl pattern here.
If you voted for the Midnight Magic Shawl, then you're in luck! We added the free pattern for that, too. Find it right here!
Easy Dreamy Shawl Midnight Magic Shawl
Leave a comment below to cast your vote!
Read NextHeartland Crochet Triangle Shawl
Your Recently Viewed Projects
Thanks for your comment. Don't forget to share!
JennyBee1
Aug 19, 2013
Thanks for all your votes! The winner of the Shawl Showdown is the Easy Dreamy Shawl; get the free pattern right here: http://www.allfreecrochet.com/Shawls/Easy-Dreamy-Shawl-from-Red-Heart-Yarn --editors of AllFreeCrochet
rroma 9610010
Aug 19, 2013
Which one is the winner? When will we get the pattern? Hope it is Easy Dreamy.
iris5223 8579731
Aug 18, 2013
I like the Midnight Magic Shawl... Its color is amazing and it is a shawl you can wear all year long, not only on wintertime.
tiffanygracey2
Aug 17, 2013
i like the midnight magic shawl the best. It looks like something I can make.
johnsofr 3619936
Aug 17, 2013
Easy Dreamy because of the style and color. Also it looks easy and quick to crochet.
carmelle121 369421 5
Aug 16, 2013
Maybe it's because of the color... I prefer Easy Dreamy Shawl.
Simply My Baby
Aug 16, 2013
Both shawls are lovely but my preference is the Easy Dreamy Shawl.
bandnicholls 39042 99
Aug 16, 2013
The Easy Dream Shawl is my preference, but the Midnight Magic Shawl is also very nice. Really would like the pattern for both if possible.
tooearly4me 139295 2
Aug 16, 2013
I love the 'easy dreamy shawl." I like how feminine it looks. I hope it wins!
joekie 3688972
Aug 16, 2013
I definitely like the "EASY DREAMY SHAWL" the best!!! Will it be able to get the pattern?
marzisaghafi 71482 35
Aug 16, 2013
I like the Easy Dream Shawl but the colours on Midnight Magic Shawl are lovely!!
Crafty Lou
Aug 15, 2013
I think the colours on the Midnight Magic Shawl are fantastic, but for a lovely all rounder it would have to be the Easy Dreamy Shawl. Love them both, shame it can only be one.
bonniewillis5225 0 737605
Aug 15, 2013
I like both the Easy Dreamy Shawl and the Midnight Magic Shawl. I would like to see them both, but if I really have to pick only one it would have to be the Easy Dreamy Shawl. It is a shame we can't have both. Bonnie in Oregon
claudetteclarke 90 77692
Aug 15, 2013
The Easy Dream Shawl is wonderful and extremely feminine and not sooooo opened s the other shawl. It also drapes beautifully over the model's dress. I would to have the pattern to make as Christmas gifts for family members.
katierossparker 02 90542
Aug 15, 2013
Please post the pattern for the "Easy Dreamy Shawl." It looks beautiful and would be a Christmas gift solution for about 5 people on my Christmas list!!!
ec3256
Aug 15, 2013
I love the Easy Dreamy Shawl - favorite - it drapes better than the other. I can't wait to crochet it.
lovesglass54
Aug 15, 2013
The Easy Dreamy Shawl is very nice and is my choice. The midnight one is just not something I would want to wear. Maybe in a different color.
steele824 3834009
Aug 15, 2013
While they are both beautiful, I like the Easy Dreamy Shawl better.
kggarcia 7663219
Aug 15, 2013
Easy Dreamy Shawl appears to be more versitle and would go anywhere so I vote it to be number 1. Rate is 4 stars
annalovcy 9129440
Aug 15, 2013
Easy Dreamy Shawl looks more sophisticated. Yet it could go with jeans and a T-shirt.
dasmom112 9757312
Aug 15, 2013
easy dreamy shawl, it can be done with a casual color or sparkle one to dress it up. love the look
mishy01 5648627
Aug 15, 2013
The easy dreamy shawl would have to be my favorite of the 2. I would love to get the pattern to make one for myself.
antcliffj 1574876
Aug 15, 2013
I like the Easy Dreamy Shawl. Would look nice next winter at a BBQ party. j
lp
Aug 15, 2013
The Easy Dreamy Shawl by far is my favorite. I would make it and wear it a lot. Laurie
nichfam4 4505066
Aug 14, 2013
The Easy Dreamy Shawl is my favorite... And I can't wait for the pattern..
elleryhouse 476922 0
Aug 14, 2013
The easy dreamy shawl really appeals to me. Just love the pattern.
vichyd 3258844
Aug 14, 2013
I believe the easy dreamy shawl is the more appealing to me. I really like the pattern scallops or shells. This is one pattern I would love to make and wear.
cvgaines 8842152
Aug 14, 2013
This is beautiful, the look is far from easy, but definitely dreamy. I vote for Easy Dreamy Shawl.
scotchbroad
Aug 14, 2013
Midnight Magic gets my vote, as you can wear it with any color, it makes it so dressy.
Moopsee
Aug 14, 2013
easy dreamy looks more lace-like -- feminine -- it wins in my book hands down.
andreamccoleman 46 61
Aug 14, 2013
They are both very pretty. The Easy dreamy shawl looks very delicate.
suparae 5927947
Aug 14, 2013
I like the Midnight Magic Shawl. It is simple and can be used with casual or dressier clothing.The colors are beautiful.
poochums910 518850 2
Aug 14, 2013
I like the Midnight Magic Shawl. There is something about the colors you used to make it. I've been looking for a shawl like this. It is beautiful. LLF
barbisharp 4472615
Aug 14, 2013
Both shawls are lovely, but I prefer the Dreamy Shawl because I'm new at crochet and it looks a tad easier for me, than the other one. Also the color is beautiful. I just love this site, so happy I found you.
funpets5 1164572
Aug 14, 2013
They look quite a bit alike but I'll take the Midnight Magic just to be different.
lhsmayersoccer 523 0818
Aug 14, 2013
While I like them both, the Easy Dreamy Shawl is exactly what I'm looking for to make as a gift this Christmas!! Can't wait for the pattern to get it started!
wrodgers1954 17873 89
Aug 14, 2013
I really like the dreamy shawl. I like the edging on it. Very versatile.
Member 9365422
Aug 14, 2013
I love the Dreamy Shawl for sure. It's one that could be dressed up or down. Can't wait to make it.
UniquityByKelleyB
Aug 14, 2013
Love the Easy Dreamy Shawl. Soon as I find the pattern I'll start on it! Cute!
bjhcpacoxnet
Aug 14, 2013
Love the soft curvyness of the easy dreamy shawl. It'll make a great gift. One for me, too.
msmanda70 5598432
Aug 14, 2013
I really enjoyed crocheting the easy dreamy shawl it is so beautiful and used caron simply soft to make it lighter! I gave to a friend who also loves it! I like the other shawl but haven't had a chance to try it yet!
justforme2003 7388 317
Aug 14, 2013
Easy Dreamy Shawl. It looks luscious and like something I would curl up with out on the porch early in the morning with my kitty sitting in my lap.
gccsctry 3709966
Aug 14, 2013
Color of Easy Dreamy Shawl is my favorite but I also like the flow of the shawl.
crissy59
Aug 14, 2013
Love both but I think the Easy Dreamy would suit me better! Need both the patterns-so lovely
fishes2x2 2342346
Aug 14, 2013
Luv the midnight shawl. It's better suited to the tropics which is where I reside.
bwalsh209 4770797
Aug 14, 2013
This was a no-brainier for me, the Easy Dreamy Shawl. I love the lacy look and the drape of this shawl.
mysticblue71
Aug 14, 2013
Easy Dreamy wins hands down! The detailed pattern is more eye catching.
pinklightning10
Aug 14, 2013
I love the Easy Dreamy design. I can see making many color variations for gifts. Cant wait for the pattern. Thank you.
kobiebritz8 470042 3
Aug 14, 2013
The Easy Dreamy shawl is definitely my special. Very pretty.
vernieuwdj 0612215
Aug 14, 2013
I like the Easy Dreamy shawl. I love making things like this to give to special friends and family. I love to crochet!!
Yellowdog9381 7789 955
Aug 14, 2013
It he Easy Dreamy is my favorite. I would love to make one for a friend for Christmas!
SouBiSou
Aug 14, 2013
Definitely Midnight Magic Shawl!!! Sophisticated and subtle texture and breathtaking color combo!!
JuBug
Aug 14, 2013
I love the Easy Dreamy shawl. I think it would look positively ethereal worked in a soft navy with a silver thread worked side-by-side with it. Hmmmmm. Might just have to try that if I can get the arthritis in my right hand to simmer down a bit.
sacramentolynn 956 5324
Aug 14, 2013
The easy Dreamy scarf looks really nice to me. Would like to try it, myself.
chriswalton48 0079 214
Aug 14, 2013
Love the colour and style...perfect for any time, day or night
reneedzn 3073135
Aug 13, 2013
I love the laciness of the Easy Dreamy Shawl. The color is perfect also.
Iyamajowu
Aug 13, 2013
Really love the open weave pattern and gradations on the Midnight Magic shawl.
txhockeygal 460401 1
Aug 13, 2013
Midnight magic all the way. Just wish I could get the yarn in my local stores!
angelaine 7648879
Aug 13, 2013
My vote is for easy dreamy, forgot to specify in previous post!
angelaine 7648879
Aug 13, 2013
Love this one! It is fancy and long enough to wrap into! Keep some really warm! Would love to see this pattern!
patlcooper 4517640
Aug 13, 2013
Not sure if this is where we vote but my vote is for the Midnight Magic Shawl. It looks open but not to delicate.
lucy49
Aug 13, 2013
I love the Easy Dreamy Shawl. I would make this one but not the Midnight Magic shawl - it's not my style or color. Can "feel" the softness of Easy Dreamy Shawl - I want these directions!
jilliangunnels 107 6661
Aug 13, 2013
Easy Dreamy Shawl! I love it! Please post the free pattern for this one! :D
rroma 9610010
Aug 13, 2013
Easy Dreamy Shawl. I want the pattern!!! Ready to start a new project.
angelfish2112 6074 416
Aug 13, 2013
Midnight magic. Love the colors and the design is different and unique.
cearle 4821344
Aug 13, 2013
Both are beautiful! But my style is more of the easy dreamy shawl.
jaynejc 1465309
Aug 13, 2013
Midnight Magic is for me. It looks interesting and I love the colors. I would like the pattern to see how hard/easy to make.
ttara 5845754
Aug 13, 2013
The Easy Dreamy Shawl wins my vote. The color and design make it my favorite.
Beannie
Aug 13, 2013
I like the fluidity of the pattern of the Easy Dreamy Shawl. It looks very feminine.
caroliner72 835441 8
Aug 13, 2013
I vote for the Midnight Magic Shawl. I love the way that any long variegated yarn will make that shawl look wonderful to match any outfit!
sandrah 3179574
Aug 13, 2013
I agree, the Easy Dreamy Shawl is the one I vote for. Color is wonderful and the pattern looks easy but very pretty.
de91212 0575106
Aug 13, 2013
The comfy cozy shawl is elegant looking and would make an excellent shawl for our prayer shawl group.
Crafter 4232925
Aug 13, 2013
Definitely the Easy Dreamy Shawl! Looks like it is a quick, easy pattern that would make a wonderful Prayer Shawl!!
heather 6598538
Aug 13, 2013
Please post the Easy Dreamy Shawl pattern. It's lovely and the turquoise color is stunning.
rareruthie 4966150
Aug 13, 2013
I love the edging around it and the fine lacy look. Hope for the pattern to be mine
Crafter 9755788
Aug 13, 2013
The Easy Dreamy Shawl is gorgeous. It is easy to make and will look good on anybody.. Color is also beautiful. I'm sure it will look good in any color.
Member 7179766
Aug 13, 2013
I really like the Easy Dreamy Shawl--sooooo pretty! Depending on the yarn and color used, it could be worn for a casual or elegant event.
coldiamond 2012538
Aug 13, 2013
I really love the dreamy shawl. It is fancy and elegant. Can wait to start on it,
Emaca42609 7951393
Aug 13, 2013
I prefer the Dreamy Shawl. It looks like it is light to wear, especially with the fall weather will be here soon. I would like to see it in a light rust color for every day wear and a silver color for a night on the town.
jacejones
Aug 13, 2013
I love the Easy Dreamy Shawl. It is more timeless and elegant. the Midnight Magic Shawl is more contemporary, modern. I would love to have the pattern for both, but I would make the Easy Dreamy Shawl for me and the Midnight Magic Shawl for a friend.jj
mzann2u
Aug 13, 2013
Easy Dreamy Shawl is the one I will make as soon as possible. But will also make the other one.
Bld814 4508135
Aug 13, 2013
I think they are both pretty but I really like the dreamy shawl. I see it in a silver grey
laurafisk210 02693 42
Aug 13, 2013
Tough choice, but I will vote for the Midnight Magic. because I like simple looking clothes .
x0z8a3b 7034369
Aug 13, 2013
I would like to see both of them enlarged. My choice is Easy Dreamy Shawl. I like Midnight Magic too.
carolhoughtaling
Aug 13, 2013
They are both very pretty but I could see myself wearing Easy Dreamy more than Midnight Magic. Thank you for the wonderful crochet patterns.
craftyrosie
Aug 13, 2013
I like the Easy Dreamy shawl better because i can see myself wearing it on a cruise in late October. Midnight Magic also nice but I don't see myself in it.
winky1 0721079
Aug 13, 2013
I love both of them. Easy Dreamy would be a great gift for a good friend as she loves that color. My daughter and daughter in law will love Midnight Magic because it is so different and they love the colors. So looks like I need to get busy - birthdays and Christmas are fast approaching:)
karibo70 7241901
Aug 13, 2013
I like both but I prefer Easy Dreamy. I can't wait for the pattern to come out if it has the most votes
wiccanlady
Aug 13, 2013
I happen to like the Easy Dreamy Shawl the best. I didn't check to see if the directions are here, but if they are, I'd really like to make it.
sittie14 9198233
Aug 13, 2013
Easy Dreamy Shawl looks so elegant. Can't wait to get the pattern.
pheishman 19480601
Aug 13, 2013
Easy Dreamy Shawl! Exactly what I've been looking for to use that "special" yarn for!
judy9861942
Aug 13, 2013
I'm definately looking forward to the pattern for the "EASY DREAMY SHAWL"...it's so pretty and soft looking!!
bettymw40 7515992
Aug 13, 2013
I like them both but would go for the Dreamy Shawl. Can't we have both???
bunnie2800 5754406
Aug 13, 2013
I vote for Easy Dreamy Shawl. I like the pattern and would like to use the pattern.
TDALE15 5367755
Aug 13, 2013
I love the Easy Dreamy Shawl it is so elegant and feminie you ca use it day or night.
patlabudz 2805567
Aug 13, 2013
Midnight Magic for sure - it is very different to all else that is out there... lets make a change !
newlin3 1357817
Aug 13, 2013
I vote for Dreamy Shawl. It's a pretty and feminine pattern. The Midnight Magic Shawl is posed with the wrong outfit in my opinion....just kind of "throws it off" for me.
leftie 9137984
Aug 13, 2013
The dreamy shawl for sure. It has a more feminine lacy feel to it.
Lgshores78006 9777 415
Aug 13, 2013
Easy Dreamy Shawl gets my vote. It looks soft and feminine.
parrina 5458193
Aug 13, 2013
I would love to make the dreamy shawl as a prayer shawl and for myself also! Lovely.
halfalake 9790404
Aug 13, 2013
Although both shawls are very nice, I would definitely want to make the "Easy Dreamy Shawl."
jasstiling 1603317
Aug 13, 2013
I have been looking for just the perfect shawl and here it is the easy dreamy shawl. I can't wait for the pattern.
Member 2976039
Aug 13, 2013
Like them both but I think if I must chose I would chose the Midnight Magic
cobbybimbimbie 182 8026
Aug 12, 2013
OOOH! The easy Dreamy Shawl looks so beautiful. <3 the drape of it in the picture.
azyurstygrrrrsiy
Aug 12, 2013
I LOVE the Easy Dreamy Shawl. I think it looks more elegant and like it would be more fun to crochet. To me the other shawl looks too symmetric and like it wouldn't be as much fun to crochet. I don't like getting stuck in a repeat mode that doesn't have much variety to it.
anaismarielle 5941 671
Aug 12, 2013
Definitely would love the easy dreamy shawl! Would be beautiful for Christmas presents!
bobgwenwebster 749 2885
Aug 12, 2013
I like the Easy Dreamy Shawl. It is something I would happily make and wear,
dcmolumby 5384722
Aug 12, 2013
The midnight magic shawl is my favorite of the 2. Of course it could be because of the color of the yarn used. At any rate it looks the most interesting to me.
yvonneellen 186700 3
Aug 12, 2013
Midnight Magic Shawl gets my vote. Looks a bit more sophisticated.
mymy 0278909
Aug 12, 2013
Midnight Magic. I like that the stitch is a little more of a unique stitch. Easy Dreamy is pretty, but the Midnight Magic would be the one I would like to try.
bsa4two
Aug 12, 2013
midnight magic, even tho I think I know this pattern already. It just flows better!;-)
51bumblebee 986059 3
Aug 12, 2013
My vote is for the " Easy Dreamy Shawl", I like it so much! Thanks You!
Bernie D
Aug 12, 2013
The easy dreamy shawl...... It appears to be able to do up in shorter time than others, I hope..............love the look....thanks
cocoinbonita 23658 95
Aug 12, 2013
Midnight magic shawl. I probably won't be able to recreate it, but I will give it a shot.
mercygrace4peace 5 897077
Aug 12, 2013
My vote is for the easy dreamy shawl. Like the pattern; so much more interesting and I think it does more of a 'job' that the shawl is supposed to do...in covering you up and warding off the draft. Thank you. Mercedes
heidihillnyc 56983 58
Aug 12, 2013
midnight magic I like simple repeats in patterns,and esp this one,as it does not need an edging
Macheow
Aug 12, 2013
Easy Dreamy Shawl because it seems more warm and inviting and yhe other appears to me to be more hars and cold/stiff!
nanceann
Aug 12, 2013
I like both, it is hard to pick just one. I would pick the Midnight Magic first. then the Dreamy Shawl to make last.
venabelles
Aug 12, 2013
I like the plain at this time - Midnight Magic intrigues me; this looks like it would work up nicely.
Judichan 8641075
Aug 12, 2013
the Dreamy one of course; how could you not love that edging? The other one is nice too...but I think it looks simply plain in comparison...
Member 0127681
Aug 12, 2013
I like the dream shawl, Don't know if its easier than the other one but, I love the color and I have some yarn in just that color too. Also, the way the model is posed in it makes the shawl look even more dramatic....yes to the dream shawl
MsOHaraP 0570963
Aug 12, 2013
I would like to see the easy dreamy shawl. It looks very classy.
naddy41999 0580355
Aug 12, 2013
Easy Dreamy Shawl please ! I just purchased that same color yarn so I'm excited ! Would love to have the pattern so I can make one exactly that color :D Love it ... Thanks and good luck to everyone !
nwfldeaconswife 35 25472
Aug 12, 2013
The Easy Dreamy Shawl appeals to me more. The design of the lace is both striking and simple. The Easy Dreamy Shawl could comfortably go classy casual or dramatic evening, especially if it is worked up in jewel colors with a little shimmer in them.
JulieH9154
Aug 12, 2013
The Easy Dreamy Shawl looks prettier than the other. The lace stitch stands out for me.
CharLarrSF
Aug 12, 2013
Easy Dreamy catches my eye first, so I guess I will give it my vote. BUT I can't help but wonder what I would think if I saw the Magic Midnight in a solid or different color pattern with edging. Hope to see both patterns!!
dabailli 1767400
Aug 12, 2013
Why not both?? If I have to choose, I guess I'll go with the crowd and say Easy Dreamy Shawl, since the Midnight Magic Shawl is too dark to really be able to see how the stitches look.
nardimichelle 6002 697
Aug 12, 2013
Midnight magic shawl, it looks more up-to-date and cooler than easy dreamy. MIDNIGHT MAGIC SHAWL for sure!!!!!!!!!!!!!
zeppypaige 5094391
Aug 12, 2013
I would love the pattern for the Easy Dreamy Shawl but thank you in advance for sharing either one :)
nanatimes11 430754 2
Aug 12, 2013
Easy d ream shaw gets my vote. I love the lacy look to it. It would make awesome Christmas gifts for my daughters and granddaughters
janetjayecrochet
Aug 12, 2013
I would like to have the pattern for the Easy Dreamy Shawl please.
jdmcoover 5236029
Aug 12, 2013
Easy dreamy shawl is my favorite, but I wouldn't mind seeing both.
Report Inappropriate Comment
Are you sure you would like to report this comment? It will be flagged for our moderators to take action.
Thank you for taking the time to improve the content on our site.
