Crochet Holiday Showdown
Crochet Holiday Pattern Showdown!
There's no doubt Thanksgiving and Christmas are both wonderful holidays. But which one do you like better? Choose between the Crocheted Nativity and the Crocheted Pilgrims. We will add the full crochet instructions for whichever pattern gets the most votes!
Leave a comment below and let us know your vote!
Crocheted Nativity Crocheted Pilgrims
Leave a comment below to cast your vote!
Read NextFlat Christmas Tree Ornament
Your Recently Viewed Projects
Thanks for your comment. Don't forget to share!
Bbartlett716
Oct 23, 2015
I am voting for the Nativity Set, been wanting it forever, it is 1 by far!!!!!!
jhaze1948
Jun 27, 2015
There are hundreds of crocheted nativities, so I vote for the pilgrims.
rainebow4548 91065 40
Dec 14, 2014
The Nativity is my choice, but I would be happy to get instructions for either one. I prefer the Nativity because this country is getting more and more anti-Christmas, and that needs to end!!
donnaorosz 2060504
Dec 26, 2013
It's true the Pilgrims landing at Plymouth Rock and the 1st Thanksgiving are very nice and important to this country's existence. More colorful, more pieces, & more meaningful is the NATIVITY!!! Without CHRISTmas and the birth of 'our King;' we wouldn't have faith & hope. Our faith allows us the knowledge that there is Heaven. Earth is just a 'stopover.' Christ began his time on Earth in humble surroundings. He is our Savior. He will come again to rule as King of ALL nations. I vote for the NATIVITY!!!
donnaorosz 2060504
Dec 26, 2013
Discovering Plymouth Rock was a start for this country. More importantly, the birth of Christ leads us in faith and hope. He was born to be our Savior/Redeemer. Pilgrims may look nice. However, just as beautiful and certainly more meaningful is the NATIVITY! Cast my vote for the NATIVITY!!!
hugadale
Dec 01, 2013
They are both adorable - but I have to go with the Crocheted Nativity scene first!!!
bja37
Nov 25, 2013
I haven't made either pattern but I love both of them. If I had to pick one of them it would be the nativity. That does not take away from the other.
kagpp8 1028439
Nov 25, 2013
I love the pilgrims and they could be used in so many ways during Thanksgiving and fall
lamawa1201 1648076
Nov 25, 2013
THERE ARE MANY NATIVITY FIGURES, BUT I HAVE NEVER SEEN PILGRIMS FOR THANKSGIVING. PLEASE DO THE PILGRIMS.
Ladybug99
Nov 24, 2013
I would love to have both but if I have to vote for one I guess I will vote for Thanksgiving since I have fewer Thanksgiving things.
jdis2 0805219
Nov 24, 2013
I would love to of had the patterns now so I could make them for Thanksgiving and Christmas They look fun to do
mdeysenroth0627
Nov 24, 2013
I love the little lambs in the Nativity. I made a crocheted Nativity for my mother many years ago, so I am partial to that one.
amistico 6227563
Nov 24, 2013
Bellissimi entrambi, ma io voto per la nativit. Potrei ricevere le istruzioni (pattern)?
Ryterski
Nov 23, 2013
I'd like to see both patterns, can't choose!!! But thanks, and please, even if it's not free, make the pattern that doesn't win available, I'd be willing to buy it.
baiversen 2942573
Nov 23, 2013
I love the Nativity Scene...Jesus is the reason for the season....
sallyj
Nov 22, 2013
I have made a similar nativity set for my grandson. Would love to make the pilgrims. I vote for both since they are adorable and would make great gifts.
lmwrench 7958979
Nov 22, 2013
Pilgrims!!!!! I've seen plenty of different Nativity sets, but never any pilgrims. :)
Candycrunch14 3167 996
Nov 22, 2013
I LOVE BOTH OF THEM, but would enjoy making the Nativity set for now.
Natashaann
Nov 22, 2013
Both are adorable but the nativity is my fave even if it does look difficult to make.
jdukti 4485495
Nov 20, 2013
Made a fabric nativity for my children and would like to make a crochet one for the grandchildren.
KMANDART 0205368
Nov 19, 2013
I think I'd have to say Thanksgiving. Both holidays bring the family together, but with Christmas brings such stress of dinner & gifts (sometimes disappointing to the kids) & entertaining. Sure, T-day is a big dinner day, but usually relaxing afterwards.
lbtluvschocolate 3 871622
Nov 19, 2013
I like the Nativity set! The grand-kids can play with this one and not have to worry about breaking them.
pauline 4848973
Nov 19, 2013
The nativity is great my first choice, would like the pilgrims pattern to do as well
pauline 4848973
Nov 19, 2013
the nativity is my favourite but would like the pilgrims as well to do
livicia
Nov 19, 2013
the nativity as christmas but also the thanksgivivg one. both so cute it is hard to choose
dsteggs
Nov 19, 2013
I prefer the nativity and agree that it would allow the g-kids to re-create the Christmas story in their own words and actions.... fun, and sweet.
kapoeck 0209882
Nov 19, 2013
Definitely the Nativity! This is one of the prettiest versions I've seen.
granmaroe
Nov 19, 2013
They are both adorable, but I would choose the Nativity Scene. I like having hands-on things for the grandkids. They could use this to tell the Christmas Story in their own words. It would make for a great video!
andersonwendy21 19 46331
Nov 19, 2013
I love the Nativity, and would love to have the pattern (As a Canadian, there are no "pilgrim's" in my country's heritage, so I wouldn'tbe likely to make them, though they are very cute.)
tinadudgeon2000 57 54135
Nov 19, 2013
The Nativity would be a challenge for me but I would give it as try
hndne2003 0594817
Nov 19, 2013
I would love to have both patterns too, but since i have to choose only one I choose the Nativity :)
gerihilton22 87358 71
Nov 19, 2013
I love both for different reasons but since i have to choose one, so I choose the nativity scene. Geri
lmhoover 8507229
Nov 19, 2013
I love both of them. but if I have to pick one , the pilgrims since it is so close to Thanksgiving.
Granny Pat
Nov 19, 2013
CHRISTMAS FAR ABOVE THANKSGIVING! IT IS THE REASON WE LOVE ONE ANOTHER! CHRIST IN OUR HEARTS! THANKSGIVING IS TO REFLECT ON OUR FAMILIES AND OUR BLESSINGS!
joyceannanderson 7 687700
Nov 19, 2013
Love the pilgrims. There is already an overload of Christmas patterns out there.
tonne 2235383
Nov 19, 2013
Love the Pilgrims. Too many Christmas patterns already and nothing for Thanksgiving. I would definitely make thes for myself as well as friends.
Chris Dennis
Nov 19, 2013
The Nativity scene is darling. Christmas is the only holiday we decorate for. The pilgrims are cute, but the Nativity wins in our house.
lantzs 6325960
Nov 19, 2013
think the Thanksgiving one is the nicest pattern but want both patterns ... would make both
cherylbedell 50968 83
Nov 19, 2013
so many favored the christmas ones but if we think about it the pilgrims gave us tradition of giving thanks and if you really think about it Thanksgiving is really not shown in stores and so should be valued as part of our heritage for sure. I vote for the pilgrims and for ideas maybe make them to place in a basket for a family that otherwise would not be able to gather and eat.
pinklightning10
Nov 19, 2013
I think both are adorable; but I've always been more drawn to Christmas, so would definately make Nativity first. Thank you.
danandlinbeasley 9 450303
Nov 19, 2013
I absolutely love both of these patterns but since I have to choose, it would have to be the Nativity. Thank you.
popkrn3 2805471
Nov 19, 2013
They are both equally wonderful patterns for the two different holidays.
popkrn3 2805471
Nov 19, 2013
They are both equally wonderful patterns for the two different holidays.
mariaisabelpalomin o 3189093
Nov 19, 2013
Estan divinos! Pero prefiero el pesebre de navidad. Desde Colombia lo felicito por tan bellos patrones en crochet. Mil gracias
frogger1053 670963 4
Nov 19, 2013
The nativity is my choice. It's what it stands for. The fact that Jesus came to pay for our sins. Something we cannot do. Also, it's a reminder to keep the meaning of Christmas in our hearts year round. It does help us to treat others better than normal. I am striving to get better at it. Thanksgiving is important in that we give thanks for the many blessings in our lives. Sometimes you have to stop and give great thought to that when many things are going badly! But, it is about spending time with family and growing closer to each other instead of far apart.
frogger1053 670963 4
Nov 19, 2013
I've not made the nativity yet but plan to. The thing is to remember what the nativity stands for and keep Christmas in your heart year round. It's something I strive for but am not even close to good at. But perserverance is the key! Thanksgiving is important in that yes it's a family day and that is greatly important. But Christ's coming is a far and away more important day!
arlene o
Nov 19, 2013
Thanksgiving as it is only about family. (While it is true that Thanksgiving is an American holiday, it is also true that non-Christians do not celebrate Christmas.)
pbivins 5526593
Nov 19, 2013
I prefer the pilgrims, because I have a lot of Christmas decorations and the pilgrims are really cute, and remind me that I have a lot to be thankful for.
ritavercruyssen 10 09586
Nov 19, 2013
the nativity that I would make since we do not celebrate thanksgiving in europ
jkharvey 6087810
Nov 19, 2013
I would like to make the nativity set, it would have great worldwide appeal
jasdmyers 8217859
Nov 19, 2013
Though both are special, I love the nativity pattern, and would probably make at least one set.
Silverfox
Nov 18, 2013
I love the nativity set! I generally collect a set each year and I will love adding this one to my collection.
Lucy B
Nov 18, 2013
Would like to make the Nativity to replace the one I gave to my daughter. It was made by my dad when I was a child. I will give this one to my granddaughter when she grows up.
curiousgeorgieous
Nov 18, 2013
I much prefer the Nativity, although the pilgrims are too adorable for words!
jdnolies
Nov 18, 2013
I love the Nativity, the pilgrims are really nice too but I vote for the Nativity.
MarMc
Nov 18, 2013
There are many patterns for Christmas, not so many for Thanksgiving(except turkeys). I want to make to make the Pilgrims.
CroKnit
Nov 18, 2013
Both patterns are very cute! As far as the real holidays go, Christmas by a landslide! :)
pfidget
Nov 18, 2013
Would love to have the nativity for my daughter...but I like the pilgrims too..Thanksgiving gets cheated.
evnmegsmom 2400657
Nov 18, 2013
I would love to have a nativity pattern for free. Would make great gifts for my church family.
amandalb22
Nov 18, 2013
Sooo cute!!!! Pilgrims only because I feel we should celebrate it before Christmas, maybe because I born the day after Christmas and I always feel like everyone is trying to rush Christmas. We should be thankful for each day we have :D
grannyanniewalrus5 0 8110763
Nov 18, 2013
Boy, this is a tough one. I like both holidays, but, because I have a ceramic nativity, I think I would like the pilgrims first, and maybe later on get the nativity. It would be something nice to make for the grandkids as they grow and get out on their own.
bookkm 6570916
Nov 18, 2013
I like the pilgrims better but those itty bitty lambs are awesome!
dtjblau 9224484
Nov 18, 2013
I think there should be more focus on Thanksgiving things to make, but I do like the nativity.
katkincheloe
Nov 18, 2013
Love them both!! So cute!! If I HAVE to chose, I would chose the pilgrims!
myredsunfire2004 8 947769
Nov 18, 2013
Love the patterns.The nativity set is beautifully done.
sewngram5 2649900
Nov 18, 2013
I love both, but I am with some of the others it is hard to find Pilgrims so I choose the Pilgrims!
scitten 5909452
Nov 18, 2013
Decisions, decisions - I like them both for different reasons! I pick the Nativity. Maybe I sould have picked the Pilgrims?
pat18054 2811995
Nov 18, 2013
It's very hard to decide which project I would like to do the most. But if I have to choose, I love the happy faces on the pilgrims. So I would like to do the Pilgrim project.
jmlaroc 9060361
Nov 18, 2013
Like both but my preference is the pilgrims, very hard to find patterns for these figures.Realy hope you will supply BOTH. Thanks.
Aeaton
Nov 18, 2013
Pilgrims, there are so few thanksgiving themed items other than turkeys and so many Christmas themed items
praisnhim2day 4436 728
Nov 18, 2013
I would have to to with the nativity, although I do like them both.
kcogan1 3693630
Nov 18, 2013
they are great so cute would love to make them as a fgift as well the nativity
crocheting prayerm ama
Nov 18, 2013
these are adorable! and the basic patterns could be used for some many other holidays!! have to go with the nativity tho, the noses on the pilgrims are huge - but cute!!
blueangel1117 5045 150
Nov 18, 2013
I really like them both very much !! wish you would post both of them so that we could make the one we want this year and then get ahead start on next years project. Thanks :)
charber59 2236845
Nov 18, 2013
This is tough, I like both. I guess maybe the Nativity set a little better. But I would like the patterns for both! :-D
opfor473 7770193
Nov 18, 2013
I love both of them....I will choose Nativity at this time only because of the time I would have to complete. But would love both patterns
kjrd2 1252027
Nov 18, 2013
the Pilgrims, there are tons of things for the X-mas season and too few for Thanksgiving
msturdivant418 190 3255
Nov 18, 2013
I love them both! So difficult to choose! :( If I have to, I'd go with the nativity.
cokebear 8736662
Nov 18, 2013
I love them both! I'm voting for the Nativity ones...for my grandkids! Thanks
juliatasmer 673921 2
Nov 18, 2013
The Nativity scene looks lovely and would be great to crochet for my grandchildren.
recipefanatic 1525 703
Nov 18, 2013
I love them both! But if I have to make a choice...the Pilgrims. :)
Crafter 19613
Nov 18, 2013
I love the Nativity. I like them both, but I like the Nativity better.
Mabelmcconnell 589 0392
Nov 18, 2013
The crochet Nativity! Gives us time to do them for Christmas.
tmanley 3309895
Nov 18, 2013
Ok I change my vote to the Pilgrims since I can't find the pattern for them! The pattern for the Nativity is here: http://www.allfreecrochet.com/Christmas-Crochet/Red-Heart-Holiday-eBook/ct/1 Thanks!
cindy961959 471835 1
Nov 18, 2013
They are both nice and would love either one...but my vote has to go to the Nativity
tmanley 3309895
Nov 18, 2013
Nativity set. I think the pilgrims are a cuter set but love the whole nativity idea so I vote nativity. Why can't we get both?!!!
jamieanthony 74620 51
Nov 18, 2013
They're both so cute! I think I like the nativity the best.
vgosbee 2288026
Nov 18, 2013
Nativity set how cute is that and then we don't get upset when little hands want to touch!
babsymama
Nov 18, 2013
They are both darling but thw Nativity would be fun to have out each year!
2peats 0454466
Nov 18, 2013
I like them both but I would say the Nativity Set. We can't get enough of what Christmas is really all about - so great job on the Nativity. Have a blessed Thanksgiving and a Merry Christmas.
marie1069
Nov 18, 2013
I would like to get the Nativity set, it is so pretty, and would be a wonderful gift too!
rosumner 6461349
Nov 18, 2013
Nativity - would stay out much longer for us and it would give me more time to make them right now - if I can get through the other projects and half-dones on the list...sigh
judynutting719 208 2181
Nov 18, 2013
Love both. Hope they are not too hard. I am still learning.
droyle 9444630
Nov 18, 2013
Both of them are beautiful but I would choose the Nativity right now since it's close to Christmas.
Member 6251486
Nov 18, 2013
Both are way cute, but I vote nativity. There would be more time to make it, and I collect Nativities.
mkopp98857 9082343
Nov 18, 2013
Oh my both are nice. I lean towards the nativity because you can leave it out longer.
Cordistew
Nov 18, 2013
I really love them both! However, I have not seen a crochet nativity scene before so I am really intrigued and hope that I will get to make one for my own household this Christmas! :-)
peggyclyde 0722376
Nov 18, 2013
Such a hard choice. My choice is the nativity. I love both of them. In the future, could you post both of them? Thanks.
mcknight 4550567
Nov 18, 2013
I like both, but because I have to choose, I will pick the nativity.
7cerickson 5781320
Nov 18, 2013
I love them both, but if I have to choose I collect Nativvities :)
lolasillito 814275 4
Nov 18, 2013
I really like the Navitiy one it is so cute, and Christimas is my most favorite time of year. And I love to decorate and make things for Christmas.
sassydeborah2 3099 475
Nov 18, 2013
I want both!!!! If I really must choose, the Nativity. You could post the Pilgrims now and the Nativity in a couple of weeks!
paghs 3885806
Nov 18, 2013
Nativity! I agree with others that the pilgrim faces need a little work.
quiltingqueen57 75 37225
Nov 18, 2013
I like them both but if I have to choose I would choose the nativity
quiltingqueen57 75 37225
Nov 18, 2013
I really like them both but if I have to choose it would be the nativity
Sewhappy2sew
Nov 18, 2013
I like the Pilgrims, they are both adorable though & I'd love to see both patterns.
allaboutdawgs 0012 810
Nov 18, 2013
I prefer the nativity as the pilgrim's have funny looking noses.
susandsmd 4166045
Nov 18, 2013
I like the looks of the Nativity better than the Pilgrims. Thanks for letting me look and vote.
nolebabe2 3448640
Nov 18, 2013
Love them both .. but if I have to choose the Pilgrims.. there are all kinds of Christmas things.. but not a lot for Thanksgiving.
zeppypaige 5094391
Nov 18, 2013
I can't decide!! I like them both but I guess if I have to choose one I will go with the Nativity set. Thank you in advance for sharing either one :)
nfhcah 0512784
Nov 18, 2013
Nativity because I have found patterns for pilgrims at other websites but not for a nativity scene.
vettertrudy 193271 3
Nov 18, 2013
love both but prefer the pilgrim for some of my less religious friends thank you
momofcrfm 7943032
Nov 18, 2013
I've already made the pilgrims, but would love the nativity. I collect nativities so I'd have to say that would be the best pattern.
tvstutz 4867138
Nov 18, 2013
I'm always on the look out for nativity crafts, but I have to say I'm not over fond of this one. The pilgrims are cute, but I don't know that I'd make them, I don't really decorate for Thanksgiving.
Report Inappropriate Comment
Are you sure you would like to report this comment? It will be flagged for our moderators to take action.
Thank you for taking the time to improve the content on our site.
